Nestled in the heart of Conway, New Hampshire, Lucy’s Ice Cream Shop offers a delightful escape for ice cream lovers seeking quality, creativity, and genuine warmth. This charming ice cream shop at 76 Main St is much more than a simple dessert stop—it's a community favorite where local flavor and friendly service come together to create an inviting atmosphere that’s hard to beat.
What truly sets Lucy’s apart is its dedication to crafting homemade ice cream that excites and satisfies even the most discerning palettes. One customer, who proudly identifies as an ice cream connoisseur having sampled treats in 28 countries and over 30 states, confessed that Lucy’s exceeded her expectations despite the town’s modest size. And it’s easy to see why—each scoop bursts with rich, creamy texture and authentic flavor that melts smoothly on the tongue, offering a nostalgic yet fresh experience.
The menu itself invites creativity. From more traditional soft serve options to intriguing, fun flavors you won’t find elsewhere locally, Lucy’s accommodates a variety of tastes and dietary needs. For instance, the peanut butter ice cream is a standout, generously packed with the comforting land of nuts that peanut butter lovers crave, while a caramel soft serve option has been praised for its luscious, velvety sweetness. Even guests with allergies feel at ease, as the staff patiently explain available dairy-free choices, creating an inclusive space for families.
But Lucy’s isn’t just about the ice cream; it’s about the entire experience. The moment you approach the shop, the friendly, quick service shines—no long waits even on busy Saturdays, coupled with a spotless, inviting environment both inside and on the patio. Customers have often remarked on the staff’s genuine kindness and the way they effortlessly make children and shy patrons feel welcome, proving that at Lucy’s, great service is as nourishing as the ice cream itself.
Whether you’re seeking a cherry coke float bursting with refreshing fizz and sweetness or a made-to-order creation combining unique flavors, Lucy’s Ice Cream Shop delivers with affordable prices and charm. It stands as a sweet beacon in Conway, a place to pause, indulge, and share moments of joy wrapped in creamy goodness. For locals and travelers alike, Lucy’s is not just an ice cream stop—it’s a heartfelt invitation to savor life’s simple pleasures.
For a taste of New Hampshire’s sweetest spot, don’t miss Lucy’s Ice Cream Shop—your next indulgent treat is waiting at the corner of Main Street.
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
621 White Mountain Hwy, Conway, NH 03818, United States
43 Pl. de l'Oscambre, 03140 Chantelle, France
Central Department Store CentralFestival Chiangmai, Tambon Fa Ham, Amphoe Mueang Chiang Mai, Chang Wat Chiang Mai 50000, Thailand
C. Marcos Ruiloba Palazuelos, 10, 39011 Santander, Cantabria, Spain
4/33 Horus Bend, Bibra Lake WA 6163, Australia
Station 3.vhub seafood restaurant Near paradise garden Front beach station3 near paradise garden, Station 3, boracay, Malay, 5608 Aklan, Philippines
Discover new menus and trending dishes on Menustic.
Menustic helps you discover menus from restaurants, cafés, and bars around the world. Explore destinations, compare dishes and prices, and decide where to eat or drink — Fantastic Menus, One Click Away.
© 2026 Menustic. Built to help people discover menus and decide what to eat and drink.
Elizabeth
12/12/2025
Stopped by on a Saturday afternoon & there was no line! Service was quick & friendly. Ice cream was delicious!
Han Jang
02/12/2025
I consider myself an ice cream connoisseur. I will eat Dairy Queen, but recognize it's not "good." Whenever I travel, I make it a point to get to know the local ice cream shops. I've now had ice cream in 28 countries, 30 states, and countless cities. And I normally gravitate towards the housemade offerings. My expectations for Lucy's were low, as it was in this tiny town with not much competition. But wow, all the flavors I tried were delicious! Perfect texture and balance of ingredients. I ultimately chose maple (when in Rome) and appreciated that whipped cream, sprinkles, and a cherry were complimentary. Highly recommend for post-hiking/exploring.
Joe Oser
23/11/2025
Just came back from Lucy's ice cream. It was raining so it wasn't very busy . The service and ice cream were both excellent, I also noticed right away how clean the shop was ,even the patio was spotless. The staff were great and friendly. My only problem is I live close by. Keep up the great work
Donelle Smith
14/11/2025
Stopped here after a long day of work up in intervale/Jackson area and wanted ice cream real bad and no dairy queens were 9pen @ 5pm on a Monday??!! Well I'm happy they weren't because I saw Lucy's on maps and tried that and I don't regret it. Peanut butter ice cream lover here and they delivered all the peanut butter I wanted. There was a 3 person crew and they were all very kind and pleasant. And the ice cream shop is the cutest I've seen. It's colorful and catches the eye. You can't miss it when you're driving by it. will be stopping here on my way home every time I work up here now!
Kea Nelson
14/11/2025
Amazing and affordable ice cream shop. The owners and all the employees were all extremely Nice. Even tho they had a little bit of a line and was actually getting ready to close when we got there they made sure they greeted each and every customer that was there. My daughter is very shy when it comes to anyone who is new or a stranger and they made her feel VERY comfortable which actually made me feel very comfortable and happy as well. If your ever in the Conway village and you are looking for something to help you cool down and a little sweet and affordable with great service and smiles that are contagious I recommend going to Lucy's I promise you wont be disappointed. If I could give more than 5 stars I would. Deff going back there before they are closed for the season.
Katie M
02/11/2025
We enjoyed our visit here! We had no line, no waiting when we got to the window. My older. Hold has a PN/TN allergy and they were very clear with their serving response to that. He was excited for so many soft serve choices. My son chose the Caramel soft serve and he loves it! My you get child has a dairy allergy - even though the website showed at least 4 options, there was only one dairy-free choice when we got there. We were told that the dairy-free selections are hard to come by right now. So, my daughter tried the strawberry lemonade sorbet. She didn't love it, unfortunately. I had a sundae and it was very good - there was lots of topping! Friendly service!!
Barbara Haley
22/10/2025
If you like soft serve ice cream you should check out Lucy's. They have fun flavor options that we haven't seen anywhere else locally, and you can create your own interesting combinations. It's different than the average ice cream shop...which makes for a nice change. Staff were all very friendly!
Cierra Gonzalo
14/09/2025
Quick service in a convenient spot with lots of flavor options! I got a cherry coke float which was delicious! Reasonable prices:)